Artificial intelligence offers opportunities to improve the efficiency of international commercial dispute resolution, while raising concerns about information security. How can dispute resolution institutions make effective use of the technology while managing its risks?
In a series of interviews on the sidelines of the Fifth Seminar of the International Commercial Expert Committee and Reappointment Ceremony of Expert Members, four experts shared their perspectives on using AI as an assistive tool while maintaining human responsibility for decisions.
Anna Joubin-Bret, secretary-general of the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law, said she sees AI and technology as tools that can help people work more efficiently, sort out information, and make decisions.
She praised Chinese judicial authorities for their willingness to embrace AI as a practical tool. Rather than rejecting its use or focusing excessively on its drawbacks, Chinese judicial authorities are exploring how it can assist their work, an approach she viewed positively, she said.
Zhou Hanmin, a member of the Standing Committee of the 14th National Committee of the Chinese People's Political Consultative Conference and chairman of the Shanghai Public Diplomacy Association, highlighted AI's potential to support the integration of mediation, arbitration and litigation in international commercial dispute resolution.
AI can help enterprises and others involved in disputes conduct preliminary research and better understand the issues they face, Zhou said. However, he stressed that AI remains an auxiliary tool and cannot take the place of human decision-makers or adjudicators.
Zhou identified information security and the protection of parties' privacy as essential considerations when using AI. He cautioned against indiscriminately feeding legal information into AI systems and emphasized the need to protect information involved in mediation, arbitration and litigation, noting that information relating to the proceedings should not be disclosed before a judgment is issued.
Used appropriately, AI can support China's foreign-related rule of law development, Chinese enterprises expanding overseas, and the work of courts and the International Commercial Expert Committee, he said.
Amapola Grijalva, senior partner of World Trade Investors Group and founding executive vice-president of the China Chamber of Commerce in Mexico, said technological resources are likely to become an important part of future litigation.
She emphasized the need to manage AI properly and make it serve the needs of its users. While some people are apprehensive about its application in dispute resolution, she encouraged a constructive approach to tools that can make work easier, more flexible and faster. Human involvement nevertheless remains necessary to ensure precision and accuracy, she added.
Mark Feldman, president of the Guangzhou Court of International Arbitration and professor of law and executive dean of Peking University School of Transnational Law, focused on balancing efficiency gains with due process.
As institutions and individuals use AI, they need to distinguish between appropriate and inappropriate uses of the technology, he said.
Feldman highlighted the right to be heard as a fundamental safeguard requiring particular attention. Institutions must carefully consider when that right could be put at risk, especially where parties' submissions are being processed primarily by machines.
He advocated embracing technological innovation while preserving this right. He anticipated considerable experimentation by dispute resolution institutions and educational institutions as they explore different approaches to responsible AI use.
The task, he said, is to identify which approaches work, recognize when the use of AI places the right to be heard at excessive risk, and secure meaningful improvements in efficiency while maintaining procedural safeguards.