
Susan Finder(US)
Permanent Scholar of Transnational Law School, Peking University
Some old friends here today will remember the very hot day in August 2018, when the Supreme People’s Court’s China International Commercial Court’s (CICC) International Expert Committee (CICC expert committee) had its first meeting in Beijing. One of my many memories of that day is that representatives of other central departments admired the Supreme People’s Court for having established a multinational international commercial expert committee. The CICC expert committee should play a more active role, or in my view, make a real contribution. That contribution should be multidimensional—it should make a contribution to the CICC, the Chinese courts, to the development of transnational law in China and internationally, and also improve understanding among Chinese and non-Chinese legal professionals and legal professionals in training. It is a rare central level multinational think tank. In my view, it requires each expert to step forward and take more responsibility. I’ll start by making some suggestions from my own professional experience. Since I have had the great pleasure of participating in the education of young Chinese legal professionals over the past 10 + years, I can contribute some ideas related to inspiring and educating young people. Others will be able to provide suggestions from their own professional experience, and I invite other members to contact me. Developing the potential of this expert committee needs everyone’s ideas and contribution.
The goal is to make a real contribution that meets the needs of relevant institutions, complies with relevant regulations and draws on the varied expertise and situation of each expert. If the some of the best uses of the CICC’s expert committee involves both Chinese and foreign members visiting courts or judicial colleges, I suggest that the procedures by which foreigners are able to visit in person or online or otherwise interact with the Chinese courts and their personnel be speeded up, so that an “express lane” is available for the foreign experts.
The following are my suggestions:
1) Drawing on the expertise of the members of the CICC expert committee, all of whom are leading practitioners and scholars from China and the entire world, I suggest drawing on the practice of Chinese and foreign court-related organizations. The Chinee practice would include the Supreme People’s Court’s advisory committee and local court equivalents. Looking to practices outside of mainland China, we can look to the practice of the Standing International Forum of Commercial Courts, Hong Kong and foreign court (and arbitration commission) user or advisory committees. All of them issue reports, sometimes based on investigations or the sharing of multinational experience, that complement the work of the court or arbitration institution. Experts may be willing to volunteer their time and involve their research assistants. Foreign court and arbitration user or advisory committees are paid in prestige rather than cash.I suggest the topic of how courts use or manage the use of artificial intelligence and others are likely to have other insightful suggestions.
2) From someone involved in the teaching of young legal professionals, it would be wonderful for the expert committee to serve as interactive educational channel. I have benefitted from hearing presentations by some of the expert committee members and I know my Chinese and foreign students would as well. I spoke once at a judicial college and surmise that students there would also be interested. So, if CICC experts are interested, I suggest that arrangements could be made for experts give lectures in person (the foreign ones, when they are in China) or online to universities or research institute affiliated with the CICC, or the institutions affiliated with other expert committee members, or provide career or other guidance to students or young professionals. This should go in both directions. My 20-something year old students know how to arrange online lectures at little or no cost.
We could take the opportunity of this gathering to find out which experts might be available to participate in these activities, the extent and the form.
I hope my suggestions in rooting the Expert Committee in Chinese soil are useful to the CICC, our Shanghai host, the Shanghai International Commercial Court, other international commercial courts and arbitration institutions, as well as other colleagues.