
HUANG Meiling
Assistant Secretary-General of the International Institute for the
Unification of Private Law (UNIDROIT)
First of all, I would like to express my sincere gratitude to the Supreme People’s Court of China for its kind invitation. It is a great honor to take part in this session on “the application and development of artificial intelligence in international commercial justice.” This is a highly meaningful and equally challenging topic—in some ways, much like artificial intelligence (“AI”) itself.
AI is rapidly transforming international commercial justice. Cross-border commercial disputes typically involve multiple languages, different legal systems, complex contractual arrangements, and voluminous evidence. When used appropriately, AI can assist with multilingual legal research and translation, document review, the identification of relevant case law, the ascertainment of foreign law, and case management—thereby reducing costs, cutting delays, and improving access to dispute resolution. This matters especially for small and medium-sized enterprises. However, alongside efficiency gains, AI presents new challenges to the fairness of adjudication, legal certainty, and judicial ethics. How to strike the right balance between technological innovation and judicial safeguards is a primary issue worthy of our consideration.
In this respect, Chinese courts have already provided highly valuable practical experience. While actively promoting the application of AI in legal research, similar case identification, evidence review, document drafting assistance, and judicial administration, the Supreme People’s Court of China has also been very clear in preserving AI’s auxiliary role: regardless of how far the technology develops, adjudicative power and ultimate responsibility for judicial decisions remain firmly with judges. For international commercial justice in particular, utilizing AI, big data, and knowledge graphs to improve the efficiency of ascertaining foreign law is of real practical significance. This approach—embracing technology proactively while clearly defining its legal and ethical boundaries—offers the international community a valuable model of practice.
Given the time available, I would like to briefly share two observations on the issue above.
First, the efficiency gains brought by AI must be premised on adequate procedural safeguards.
Where AI plays a substantive role in the handling of a case, the parties should, in principle, be informed of this, and should have a genuine opportunity to challenge any output that is inaccurate or unreliable. Trade secrets and other confidential information must be protected, and judges and arbitrators must remain accountable for the final decisions.
This is particularly crucial in international commercial justice. A judgment or an arbitral award must not only be accepted by the parties to the proceedings in which it was rendered, but may also need to be recognized and enforced in other jurisdictions. If the use of AI undermines due process, procedural equality between the parties, or the right to be heard, far from reducing cross-border obstacles, it may instead create new problems at the stage of recognition and enforcement.
Second, we need to discuss not only how AI can be used to resolve disputes, but also how disputes arising from AI should be resolved.
AI itself can become a source of disputes. For example, an AI system might make a business decision that causes harm, provide inaccurate professional advice, or cause loss through an algorithm whose reasoning is difficult to explain. In such cases, who should bear responsibility—the developer, the provider, the deployer, the professional user, or the platform? The injured party may have no knowledge of how the system reached its conclusion, and may find it difficult to determine who was actually in control of the system. Traditional rules on fault, causation, the burden of proof, and damages may not readily answer these questions.
The cross-border dimension adds further complexity to the challenge. AI systems can operate across jurisdictions, while liability rules may differ from one country to another. Parties may therefore struggle to determine which standard applies, who is liable, and where redress can be sought.
This is precisely the kind of question that UNIDROIT’s future work will address. Under the UNIDROIT Work Programme for the triennial period 2026–2028, we are about to launch a project on “Regulation of Digital Risks through Civil Liability Law,” which will examine the risks arising from AI, automated decision-making systems, digital platforms, and other digital applications.
As AI is integrated into judicial and arbitral proceedings, new questions of private-law liability will inevitably arise. For example, if an AI system used by a court leaks confidential information due to a technical defect or security vulnerability, how should liability be allocated among the developer, the provider, and the operator? Where arbitrators, arbitral institutions, or other private dispute resolution bodies use AI tools and this results in procedural errors, information leaks, or losses to the parties, how should the boundaries of liability be defined? These may also be questions that need to be addressed.
Our project will help legislators identify and assess digital risks and determine whether existing civil liability regimes remain adequate. On this basis, subsequent work will further examine the relevant substantive principles. Our goal is not to prescribe a single technical solution, but rather to develop a more coordinated and coherent private-law response to cross-border digital risks, while respecting different legal traditions.
Ultimately, how far AI can go in international commercial justice will depend not only on how advanced the technology is, but also on whether it can operate within an institutional framework that ensures accountability, procedural fairness, and legal certainty. Chinese courts have already accumulated invaluable experience in the field of judicial AI. UNIDROIT looks forward to further strengthening its cooperation with the Supreme People’s Court of China, combining China’s practical experience with comparative studies and regulatory coordination at the international level to jointly foster a more reliable, clear, and trustworthy legal framework.
Thank you.