
John Thomas (UK)
Member and First Chair of SIFoCC Steering Group
Former Lord Chief Justice and Head of the Judiciary of England and Wales
President of the Qatar International Court and Dispute Resolution Center (QICDRC)
I speak as President of Qatar International Court and as a member of SIFoCC Steering Committee, of which I was chairman until May 2026 (as well as former LCJ of England and Wales).
Although no one should forget the important work that needs to be done as discussed in Panel 1, without doubt the biggest issues facing International Commercial Courts arise out of the development of Artificial Intelligence (AI).
I welcome the use of AI. It will improve court efficiency and reduce cost. Many other issues arise on which work is being done through SIFoCC to ensure courts share best practice, learn from each other and find common standards.
I want to emphasise four specific points in the few available minutes:
(1) Need for the judges to be kept up to date with the use of AI in commerce, finance and international supply chains
AI poses new legal issues for business. Courts need to be sure that they are sufficiently up to date with the changes so that they can apply the right legal solution.
One example is deciding who bears the risk if generative AI gets it wrong. Is AI in such a case to be treated as a tool or an independent agent? As legislation is in many states too slow, judges need to find a solution. The approach at common law has generally been to apply existing law by treating AI as a tool.
Another example is the UNCITRAL Model Law on Electronic Trade Records (MLETR) which several counties have adopted including UK and China. Although this is a legislative solution which applies existing concepts, it will only be made to work well if applied by courts with a proper understanding of the new system.
(2) Use by the judges/parties of AI in court proceedings
There is no doubt that AI is being used by parties and courts to assist in drafting court papers, chronologies and summaries and for research. The question is the extent to which parties, lawyers for the parties, experts and judges ought to use and disclose the use of AI in submissions made to the court and in judgments produced by the court.
I hope we can reach a broad consensus on this. SIFoCC is working to this end.
If we cannot not, policy choice will be for particular countries. That choice will depend on factors such the value of the claims, use of AI in that country, the supervision over lawyers, the ability of the court to regulate its use, cost savings and the views of the judges and experts. If each country is to make its own choice, there must be a clear policy made publicly available so there are no issues on public confidence or on cross border enforcement.
(3) Use of AI in arbitrations
Courts now face an increasing number of cases where enforcement of arbitration awards are contested on grounds relating to public policy and procedural fairness.
It is essential that international standards be reached in relation to the conditions for the use of AI in arbitration. Otherwise it is likely that the use of AI will be put forward by some as yet another means of resisting enforcement.
(4) Anticipating future developments
In many states the process of improving court procedures has historically proceeded at a slow and measured pace; plenty of time could be taken to get it right. The pace at which AI is developing and the prospect of the arrival of artificial general intelligence means that this approach is no longer possible. We must anticipate the options that lie ahead. Again we can only benefit by sharing our views and working out the best common approach.