
WU Jinshui
President of Shanghai First Intermediate People's Court
In recent years, artificial intelligence(AI) has been transforming all facets of economic and social development at an unprecedented speed, breadth and depth. How to harness AI to empower judicial adjudication, especially international commercial adjudication, has become a shared challenge across national borders. Drawing on explorations of Shanghai Courts, I would like to share some observations and reflections.
I. Achievements of Shanghai’s Digital-Court development lay a solid foundation for judicial application of AI
To implement General Secretary Xi Jinping’s important instructions on “promoting the in-depth integration of scientific and technological innovations including big data and AI with judicial work”, Shanghai Courts have proactively embraced transformations and fully advanced digital-court development, achieving improvements in both case quality and procedural efficiency. For example, the Full-process Intelligent Judicial Assistance System, primarily built for court personnel, adopts digital modelling, big-data analytics and intelligent applications as its technical backbone. Deeply embedded within its knowledge repository are Shanghai Courts’ accumulated judicial experience and adjudicative rules. It delivers multiple forms of intelligent support for judges, including knowledge-graph recommendation, real-time early-warning alerts, and digital inspection and supervision of case quality. At the same time, we provide comprehensive digital litigation services for litigants. Under the Full-process Online Case-handling System, parties may participate online in all procedural phases of litigation—ranging from case‑filing, submission of materials, mediation and hearings to applications for enforcement—without leaving home. This has tangibly enhanced the parties’ sense of benefit and satisfaction regarding judicial fairness, openness, transparency and accessibility. The practical outcomes, reform concepts and methodologies generated from these earlier explorations offer valuable lessons for further advancing AI applications in judicial work.
II. Coordinating development and security to ensure steady and sound judicial deployment of AI
Yet, given potential risks brought about by AI technologies in judicial scenarios, we must uphold technology for good and precisely delineate the boundaries for AI application in adjudication. Taking the Opinions on Regulating and Strengthening the Applications of Artificial Intelligence in the Judicial Fields issued by the Supreme People’s Court as the guiding framework, three core principles shall be followed for judicial use of AI.
First, adhere to the judge-led approach and independent decision-making by end-users. No matter how sophisticated AI becomes, it can only function as an auxiliary tool and must never replace judges in adjudication. Judicial responsibility must always rest with the judge.
Second, adhere to algorithmic explainability, universality and inclusiveness. Algorithmic reasoning shall be traceable, testable and verifiable. Implicit biases and AI “hallucinations” arising from algorithmic “black boxes” shall be rectified in a timely manner, ensuring intelligent tools work equally for all users.
Third, adhere to data security and whole-chain risk control. Judicial large language models will have access to large volumes of sensitive information and important data. Their full lifecycle—from development and training to deployment—must operate in compliance with security rules and the requirements of public policy and good morals.
III. Proactively responding to the practical needs of cross-border commercial dispute resolution and exploring a future-oriented international commercial intelligent adjudication system
Compared with ordinary domestic commercial cases, cross-border commercial dispute resolution is generally plagued by such pain points as difficulties in determining offshore jurisdiction, high costs for the ascertainment of foreign law, and lengthy timelines for cross‑border service of process. These difficulties largely arise from substantial divergences among states and regions concerning rules, regulations, administration and standards. It is difficult to conduct item‑by‑item screening and comparison relying solely on human efforts, while AI technology can deliver powerful support. To take the ascertainment of foreign law as an example, traditional mechanisms for the ascertainment of foreign law have long been confronted with problems including the limited capacity of individual entity to conduct such ascertainment, prohibitive costs, protracted timelines, inconsistent standards and fragmented resources. Leveraging intelligent large language models, we can accurately adapt to the institutional features of different jurisdictions and build the “Intelligent Auxiliary System for Ascertainment of Foreign Law”. Integrating foreign‑law retrieval, in‑depth analysis of judicial precedents, push of similar cases, cross‑border legal comparison, consolidation of academic viewpoints and multilingual translation, the system can greatly improve the quality and efficiency of adjudication.
As a specialized judicial body with centralized jurisdiction over foreign-related commercial disputes within Shanghai municipality, the Shanghai International Commercial Court will fully draw upon the collective wisdom of the expert members of the International Commercial Expert Committee, working together with relevant authorities to explore and establish the institutional framework of “AI-powered analysis + human review”, and proactively yet prudently develop an intelligent adjudication system tailored to cross-border commercial dispute resolution. Upholding the spirit of openness and inclusiveness, prudence and pragmatism, and innovation and exploration, we look forward to advancing hand-in-hand with colleagues from all over the world to steadily propel this powerful engine of AI, like a one-thousand-mile-a-day steed, to run with greater stability, speed, and reach. Let us jointly contribute more Chinese wisdom and Shanghai solutions for international commercial dispute resolution in the digital-intelligence era.