In May 2026, the Regulations on Commercial Mediation of the People’s Republic of China officially came into effect, marking the formal recognition in law of commercial mediation as a voluntary, confidential, efficient and amicable means of dispute resolution. The inherent flexibility of commercial mediation means that commercial disputes can be resolved through innovative approaches. Drawing on BIMC's innovative practice in construction projects, this report illustrates the unique value of commercial mediation in resolving complex disputes.
I. Background
Construction projects are characterized by large-scale investment, long construction periods, numerous specialized processes and complex chains of performance. If construction disputes are not handled properly, even minor cases can drive up costs and cause delays, while serious ones may drag the parties into protracted litigation or arbitration procedures. In the context of the Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Greater Bay Area under the "One Country, Two Systems" framework, such disputes become even more complex, potentially involving obstacles in the choice of applicable law, evidence collection and cross-border enforcement.
In the Qianhai Shenzhen-Hongkong Modern Service Industry Cooperation Zone, there are two schools which are Shenzhen-Hong Kong integration cooperation projects. Qianwan School is the first government-invested Shenzhen–Hong Kong integration project in China with full-process participation by Hong Kong enterprises. It was constructed by a Hong Kong company, with a Hong Kong architectural firm leading multiple Hong Kong teams in charge of the entire survey, design and supervision process. Mawan School, on the other hand, adopts an optimized EPC management model (jointly contracted by a mainland company and a Hong Kong consulting engineering firm), bringing the experience and advanced international educational concepts of Hong Kong into Qianhai.
II. Innovative Practice
Commissioned by the project owner, Shenzhen Qianhai Construction Investment Holding Group Co., Ltd., BIMC provided dispute resolution services for the two schools. In practice, BIMC introduced the internationally recognized Dispute Resolution Advisor (herein referred to as “DRAd”) mechanism into commercial mediation and combined it with back-end arbitration, so that project disputes were resolved progressively through the three-tier process of “dispute resolution advisor-mediation-arbitration upon completion.” Specifically, the practice involved three explorations:
(i) Front-loading Dispute Resolution
In both projects, BIMC replaced the traditional "post-dispute intervention" approach with a "pre-dispute intervention" approach. Throughout the projects, the DRAd team participated in every progress meeting and key milestone meeting, kept a real-time view of each work stream including construction, design, quotation and approvals. Upon detecting early signs of a dispute, the team would step in promptly to defuse tensions. Once a dispute arose, mediation procedures were initiated immediately without suspending construction.
(ii) Building a Joint Shenzhen-Hong Kong Dispute Resolution Team
The differences between the legal rules of Shenzhen and Hong Kong bring challenges for dispute resolution in these projects. BIMC therefore formed a joint team comprising senior Hong Kong mediation experts well-versed in construction engineering (Hai Ming Leung , Denys Look and Norris Yang, among others) and mainland mediators with backgrounds in construction dispute resolution. The Hong Kong experts, versed in Hong Kong and international construction management rules, took the lead in designing the dispute resolution procedures. Familiar with mainland laws and regulations, government investment regulatory requirements and engineering technical specifications, the mainland experts ensured substantive compliance. The two sides had different strengths, and each made up for what the other lacked.
(iii) Replacing Confrontation with Professional Guidance
Under the new model, the DRAd first acts as a “fact clarifier” by guiding both parties to pin down the basic facts. What both sides agree on is listed out first, and what they genuinely disagree about is identified and refined separately. This prevents the parties from losing sight of the facts and simply arguing over the wording of the contract provisions. On that basis, the advisor then guides both parties to focus on “how to solve the problem” rather than “who is right and who is wrong.” Once the facts are clear and the real issues are defined, the direction of a solution usually emerges on its own.
III. Positive Social Outcomes
Both school projects were ultimately completed and delivered on schedule. In the process, a number of disputes arising from unpaid fees, delays to the construction programme, and variations to the works were all properly resolved through this mechanism. To look back and sum up, this positive outcome is evident in three main respects:
(i) A Breakthrough at the Institutional Level
Traditionally, dispute resolution in the construction sector has taken the form of “Ex post remedy.” Parties typically seek external intervention only after conflict has been intensified to a certain level. This practice explored a "full-lifecycle embedded" pathway instead. Instead of waiting until the project is finished, dispute resolution is brought in from the very start of construction and involved throughout the entire construction process. Early warning, guidance, and mediation follow one another in a connected sequence, so that the disputes are dealt with as they first emerge before they have the chance to escalate. This model breaks the entrenched cycle of "performance → dispute → dispute resolution → project delay," achieving the goal of resolving disputes without disrupting the works.For government-invested projects, this means that the programme, costs, and risks all remain under control.
(ii) Exploratory Value for high-level opening-up
Against the backdrop of "one country, two systems, and three legal jurisdictions," the alignment of rules presents a real and practical challenge. Hong Kong's construction management rules are aligned with prevailing international standards, while the mainland's construction regulatory regime follows its own logic. When two sets of rules operate within a single project, one cannot simply favour one set over the other, nor copy either of them without regard to whether it actually fits.
In this practice, BIMC explored a new pathway: the joint team, made up of experts familiar with both sets of rules, handled each specific issue individually as it arose, and aligned the two systems point by point. The Hong Kong experts ensured that procedures met international standards, while the mainland experts ensured substantive compliance with mainland regulatory requirements. The pilot at the two schools demonstrates that this model, with procedures drawing on Hong Kong's experience and substance governed by mainland regulation, is workable. It is not a simple transplantation of rules, but the identification of workable points of convergence while preserving the core strengths of each system.
(iii) Social Impact and Replicability
The two schools are major public welfare projects built in the context of the Greater Bay Area's development, and the practical and social significance of their successful, on-schedule delivery speaks for itself. What is even more valuable is that the "dispute resolution advisor plus commercial mediation" mechanism developed in this pilot is not a one-off solution. It can be replicated and applied to all types of government-invested construction projects, offering a new paradigm for resolving disputes in the construction sector.