
Lei Chen
Chair Professor of Comparative Law, School of Law,
University of Manchester, United Kingdom
Director of the Manchester China Institute
Distinguished judges, colleagues, ladies and gentlemen,
It is a great pleasure to join you today. In the few minutes available, I would like to make one central argument: international commercial mediation is undergoing a fundamental transformation. It is moving from the margins of dispute resolution into the institutional architecture of international commercial justice.
Let me highlight three developments.
First, mediation is moving from an alternative to adjudication towards integration with adjudication.
We have traditionally spoken of mediation as “alternative dispute resolution”—an alternative to courts and arbitration. I wonder whether that description remains entirely accurate. Increasingly, the important question is not whether parties should choose litigation, arbitration or mediation. It is how these processes can work together.
The CICC's One-Stop Diversified International Commercial Dispute Resolution Mechanism is particularly interesting in this respect because it brings together litigation, arbitration and mediation within an integrated framework.
The next step, in my view, is sophisticated process design: at what stage should mediation be introduced? Can early neutral evaluation help parties realistically assess their positions? When should a court encourage mediation, and when should it proceed directly to adjudication?
This leads to my first proposition: The future is not mediation instead of adjudication. It is mediation intelligently embedded within adjudication.
Second, international mediation is moving from voluntary settlement towards transnational enforceability.
This is why the Singapore Convention on Mediation matters. One of the great strengths of international arbitration has been the New York Convention and the global infrastructure it provides for the recognition and enforcement of arbitral awards.
Historically, mediation has lacked an equivalent framework. A mediated settlement was, in essence, a contract. The Singapore Convention seeks to change that by providing a framework for the cross-border enforcement of international mediated settlement agreements.
For China, there is a particularly important question. China signed the Convention in 2019 but has not yet ratified it. If China moves towards ratification, we should consider not only the Convention itself, but a broader institutional question:
How should the international enforcement regime under the Singapore Convention interact with China's existing judicial mechanisms and, particularly, with the CICC's One-Stop dispute-resolution framework? That could have considerable significance for China's role as a forum for resolving international commercial disputes.
Third, mediation is moving from exclusively human decision-support towards AI-assisted dispute resolution.
Artificial intelligence can already assist with document analysis, identify the parties' underlying interests, model settlement ranges and generate possible settlement packages.
But I do not think the most interesting question is whether AI will replace human mediators. The more realistic—and more difficult—question is: How can AI augment human mediation without undermining confidentiality, procedural fairness and trust?
Imagine a complex joint-venture dispute involving thousands of documents and numerous commercial variables. AI may be able to identify combinations of price adjustments, future supply arrangements, licensing rights and governance changes that neither party has considered.
This demonstrates something fundamental about mediation. Its comparative advantage is not simply that it may be faster or cheaper than litigation.
Its deeper advantage is remedial creativity. A court or arbitral tribunal is generally constrained by the claims before it and the remedies available under law. Mediation can potentially redesign the parties' future commercial relationship.
That capability will become increasingly important in complex cross-border disputes. Let me conclude with one observation about China.
China is unusually well positioned to contribute to the next generation of international commercial mediation. We have the CICC and its integrated dispute-resolution mechanism; major international arbitration and mediation institutions; the Singapore Convention awaiting ratification; and, most recently, the establishment of the International Organization for Mediation in Hong Kong.
The opportunity, therefore, is not simply to promote more mediation. The more ambitious task is to develop a coherent architecture in which courts, arbitration and mediation reinforce one another, while new technologies enhance rather than compromise procedural justice.
So perhaps the question for the next decade should no longer be:
“How can mediation become a more successful alternative to litigation and arbitration?”
Instead, we should ask:
“How should mediation be redesigned as an integral component of international commercial justice?”
Thank you very much.