
HUANG Jiefang
Zhou Gengsheng Chair Professor of Wuhan University
Member of the National High-End Think-Tank Institute of International Rule-of-Law Studies, Wuhan University
In 2021, at the Commemoration Conference Marking the 50th Anniversary of the Restoration of the People’s Republic of China’s Lawful Seat in the United Nations, President Xi Jinping pointed out: “Humankind is an integrated whole, and the Earth is our shared homeland. No person or country can mind its own business and stay immune from common challenges. Humanity should work with solidarity in harmony and unity, thrive together in peace, and forge ahead toward building a community with a shared future for humankind.” This important statement profoundly embodies the core value of China’s Traditional Philosophy of harmony and unity in contemporary global governance. Today, when we turn our attention to the field of international dispute settlement, this ancient Oriental wisdom of “harmony and unity” is being institutionalized into the fabric of global governance, paving a new path for win-win outcomes amid profound changes unseen in a century.
I. The Inherent Consistency Between China’s Traditional Harmony and Unity Philosophy and International Commercial Mediation
Rooted in fine traditional Chinese culture, China’s traditional philosophy of Harmony and Unity consists of two core dimensions: "he"(和) (harmony and amity), represents concordance and peace, emphasizing the coherence of multiple perspectives; and "he"(合) (integration and cooperation), stresses the mutual influence and combination of different elements. "Thriving together" means all stakeholders live and develop collaboratively through interdependence, with its core tenet encapsulated as "harmony without uniformity, mutual benefit and win-win results". International commercial mediation adopts equal consultation as its approach to restore bilateral relations, enhance mutual trust and balance competing interests, which bears profound inherent consistency with the harmony and unity philosophy. The philosophy serves as the philosophical foundation and cultural core of international commercial mediation, while international commercial mediation acts as the concrete practice and institutional embodiment of the philosophy in the field of international dispute settlement. Together, they offer an alternative path for peaceful dispute resolution to advance the building of a community with a shared future for humankind.
II. Empowerment of China’s Traditional Harmony and Unity Philosophy in Foreign-related Commercial Mediation for Dispute Resolution
China has consistently applied the harmony-oriented mediation mindset to foreign-related judicial practices. The Second Batch of Model Mediation Cases in Foreign-related Commercial and Maritime Matters released by the Supreme People’s Court refers to a cross-border payment dispute between Chinese and Uzbek parties heard by the People’s Court of New Metropolitan Area of Urumqi City. It stands as a typical model for flexible settlement of cross-border disputes. Guided by China’s Traditional Harmony and Unity Philosophy, the court abandoned rigid adjudication thinking and adopted online multilingual mediation to reconcile conflicting interests, adopt an online mulilingual mediation model to reconcile differences of interest at different level. The case concluded with a voluntary settlement reached by both parties, resolving the cross-border commercial dispute efficiently. The settlement protected the legitimate rights and interests of the Chinese and foreign party equally while sustaining the cooperative ties between Chinese and foreign commercial entities, fully demonstrating the unique strength of China’s harmony-and-unity-based mediation model in handling cross-border disputes.
III. Spiritual Resonance Between China’s Traditional Harmony and Unity Philosophy and Dispute Settlement Mechanisms of International Organizations
With the global dissemination of ancient Oriental wisdom, international specialized organizations have kept renovating their dispute settlement rules. The reform of the adjudicative functions of the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) Council is the most representative practice. Under ICAO’s constitutional instrument, a member state to a dispute may refer the dispute to the Council for decision if the dispute cannot be settled through negotiation. Historically, however, the vast majority of disputes submitted to the Council failed to produce a final ruling, with the 2025 case brought by Australia and the Netherlands against Russia being the sole exception. Against this backdrop, many legal practitioners have called for strengthening the judicial functions of the Council. Starting from 2018, the ICAO Legal Committee launched the most extensive amendments of the Rules for the Settlement of Differences since its adoption in 1957. Chinese delegation participated in the whole amendment process and contributed Chinese wisdom and Chinese proposals. The revised version of the Rules was approved by the ICAO Council and entered into force in 2024.
Notably, the new version adopted by the Legal Commission and endorsed by the Council rejected previous proposals aimed at strengthening judicial features. For instance, one of the original draft amendments proposed that the Council should be empowered to adopt provisional measures for such purposes as property preservation, evidence preservation and/or action preservation prior to a final decision in order to safeguard the rights of state parties. After thorough deliberations, such provisions with heavy judicial connotation were discarded. Another example relates to the public disclosure of case records. One view was that the Council, as a judicial body, should align with the practice of other judicial mechanisms and maintain transparency in dispute handling. Another view favored strict confidentiality, consistent with general mediation principles. The final text struck a compromise between the two, vesting the Council with discretionary power over disclosure matters. These two instances demonstrate that ICAO has adopted a dispute settlement framework prioritizing mediation and consultation, with adjudication as an alternative. Mediation takes precedence because international civil aviation depends on cooperation and a harmonious operational environment; adjudication serves as a backup to maintain uniformity of the rule of law and foster safe and orderly development of civil aviation. This procedural design featuring mediation as the primary recourse is highly consistent with China’s traditional Harmony and Unity Philosophy. It sets a typical model of combining mediation with adjudication for international dispute settlement and embodies Oriental mediation wisdom in the specific area of public international law.
IV. Institutional Implementation of China’s Traditional Harmony and Unity Philosophy in the International Organization for Mediation
The International Organization for Mediation is the world’s first intergovernmental international organization dedicated exclusively to settling international disputes through mediation. It marks a historic leap for China’s traditional Harmony and Unity Philosophy from a cultural ideology to institutional practice, filling the long-standing institutional gap in international dispute settlement mechanisms that lacked a full-time mediation body. The International Organization for Mediation has achieved rapid progress since its establishment. To date, the number of signatory states to its convention has risen to 46. In May 2026, it successfully resolved its first international maritime dispute involving parties from China and Singapore. This pioneering practice fully demonstrates the unique value of mediation in resolving complicated international controversies and offers a viable solution for the world to settle disputes peacefully.
Looking back on the application of China’s traditional Harmony and Unity Philosophy in international mediation, such philosophy is evolving from a cultural tradition into institutional practice within global governance. Distinctive Chinese governance theories and practical experience including the traditional Ma Xiwu Trial Model and the New-era Fengqiao Experience, centered on the core wisdom of "integrating trial with mediation" and "prevention prior to resolution", are expanding their influence from domestic governance to the international arena. They have elevated from local governance wisdom to the valuable resource for thought of global governance and offered an important paradigm for international commercial mediation.
Looking ahead, mediation will become an indispensable approach to international dispute settlement. This practice also verifies the timeless value of China’s traditional Harmony and Unity Philosophy that transcends geographical boundaries. It will continuously inject profound cultural strength and positive rule-of-law momentum into advancing the building of a community with a shared future for humankind.